Robert Shohet wrote:
> Ok, now I am really curious....
> > >
> > > Are you saying that you run 75 ohm coax from all the antennas to the
> > > switches and then from the antenna switches, run 50 ohm to the
> > between the switches on the towers and the outside wall of the shack all
> > lines are 75 ohm. from the switches to the antennas is 50 ohm, and from
> > outside the shack wall all the way to the radio is 50 ohm.
> Let me ask a naive question.... Let's say that the antenna really is at 50
> ohms with 1:1 swr. The you add the 75 ohm piece to bring it inside the
> shack. SWR is now (at least) 1.5:1 not including the effects of any
> reactance since the 75 ohm piece is not a multiple of a 1/2 wavelength. Now
> you go back to 50 ohm. Doesn't that multiply the mismatch by at least
> another 1.5:1? Or does that somehow reduce the mismatch by 1.5 :1? But
> then since the piece inside the shack is not a multiple of 1.5:1 and
> reactance is a factor of some unknown quantity, doesn't this create a total
> "witches brew" of the swr and impedance at the radio and amp? Please help
> me understand this.
_ 50 ohm 75 ohm 50 ohm |||
|_|------------================================--------------||| 50 ohm antenna
ok, from right to left...
on the 50 ohm line attached to the antenna the swr is 1:1
on the 75 ohm line the swr is 1.5:1
at the left end of the 75 ohm line the impedance can be anywhere from 50 to
112.5 ohms due to the impedance transformation along the line. every 1/2 wave
the 50 ohms will repeat, and half way in between at the odd multiples of 1/4
wave you get 112.5 ohms.
so on the 50 ohm line to the transmitter you can have anything from 1:1 to
on a monoband system there are 2 easy fixes if you get an impedance you don't
like... i always leave a bit extra hardline anyway so that can be trimmed to
bring it closer to the 1/2 wave multiple. or in one case (160m where trimming
1/4 wave wasn't very practical) i made the line from the hardline to the tx out
of 75 ohm rg11 which made the impedance much better.
all my systems are made like this and the only ones i have had to play with were
160m and 15m a bit, i guess i was just lucky that the others were close enough
to 1/2 wave not to bother with. you could of course measure out the hardline in
advance with an analyzer. there are also other methods like one that puts
coaxial transformers at each end, or the 50-75 ohm un-un... for hf though both
of these seem like overkill and add complexity with extra connectors and other
things to break or cause more loss than the mismatch does.
btw, on mine i always stop the hardline just outside the shack and bring rg8/213
into the shack. its just too hard to bend that catv stuff around without
> > >
> > i never measure swr on the 75 ohm cables, only one the 50 ohm ones inside
> > shack, or on the 50 ohm pieces going to the antenna when i am tuning them
> on the
> > ground. i have never had a problem with this.
> Now does this also mean that with my hardine stubs (75 ohm fused disc CATV),
> when I am making 1/4 sections of coax (to connect the stubs to each other)
> that I should have used 75 ohm coax (RG11 say) instead of 50 ohm coax
no, because the 1/4 wave stubs are meant to look like an open or short at the
end where they connect to the 50 ohm feedline the actual impedance of the stub
cable doesn't matter. so you want to keep the section of coax between them the
same as the rest of the cable that the goes to the transmitter.